When a vessel arrives before the original bills of lading, the carrier can release the cargo against a letter of indemnity (LOI). This guide follows that release from arrival to the return of the originals: why the LOI is asked for, the indemnity obligations it creates, the liability exposure it leaves, and the credit checks, approvals and delivery records it needs.
A letter of indemnity, or LOI, is a written promise to compensate the carrier for what it may suffer by doing something it would otherwise refuse to do. In physical commodity trading the case that matters here is cargo delivery without the original bills of lading. Under an order bill the carrier delivers the cargo to the party presenting an original. When the vessel arrives and no original can be presented, the carrier can release the cargo to the party asking for it, against an LOI from that party. The cargo moves. The liability for having released it to someone who may not have been entitled to it does not disappear. It moves onto the party that signed the LOI, and it stays there until the originals are back with the carrier.
This article follows that scenario from the vessel's arrival to the return of the originals. It sets out why the carrier asks for an LOI, which indemnity obligations it creates, who could still claim the cargo and what the liability exposure is while they can, why an LOI is worth only the counterparty creditworthiness behind it, and which approvals and delivery records it needs. It also sets out how those records correspond to the records a trading business keeps. It is written for the people who are asked to issue or accept an LOI at short notice: the operations teams who arrange the release, the trade finance and credit teams who answer for the exposure, the legal teams who approve the wording, and the middle office who keep the trade and the cargo it belongs to.
If the subject is new to you, start with Under an order bill the carrier delivers against an original, and an LOI is what it asks for when none can be produced. If you already issue LOIs and want the part that goes wrong quietly, start with The exposure is to whoever holds the originals and was not paid, and it lasts until the originals are back with the carrier.
Under an order bill the carrier delivers against an original, and an LOI is what it asks for when none can be produced
The bill of lading is the document the cargo is released against. A carrier that releases the cargo without an original takes the risk that the party it released to was not entitled to it, and that the real holder of the bill will claim later. The LOI is the carrier's protection against that claim.
Under an order bill, the carrier's obligation at discharge is to deliver the cargo to the party presenting an original, properly endorsed. If it delivers to anyone else, it can be liable to the holder of the bill for the value of the cargo. That liability does not depend on whether the carrier acted in good faith or whether the receiver was the buyer everybody expected.
The originals can be missing at discharge for ordinary reasons. A cargo sold and resold during the voyage passes its bills through each seller and buyer in the chain. A cargo paid for under a letter of credit sends its bills through the banks, which examine them before passing them on. On a short voyage the vessel can simply arrive before the documents do. In each case the cargo is ready, the receiver wants it, and the vessel waits.
Waiting has its own cost. Time at the discharge port can run against the laytime the charter allows, and demurrage follows. That cost is the pressure behind a request for an LOI, and it arrives at a moment when nobody has time to read a wording closely.
Whether the waiting becomes a demurrage claim, and who ends up paying it, is decided later and from other documents. How that claim is assembled is set out here. Laytime and Demurrage: Why the Cost Is Decided After the Ship Has Gone
The carrier can refuse. It is not obliged to release the cargo without an original, and its own liability insurance can exclude, or cover only at its insurer's discretion, a liability that arises from delivery without the bill. That exclusion is the reason the carrier asks for an LOI, and the reason it asks for one in a form it recognises.
The bill is the document the cargo is released against, and a cargo released without one leaves its own risks behind. What the bill records and how it corresponds to the contract and the delivery records is set out here. Bill of Lading: Why It Records What Was Loaded, Not What Was Agreed
An LOI runs from the party asking for the cargo to the carrier, and in a chain each party asks the next for one back
The carrier takes the LOI from the party that instructs it to release the cargo, which is the charterer in a chartered voyage. Where that party is not the final receiver, it asks its own buyer for a matching LOI, and the buyer asks the next. The result is a chain of separate promises, each only as good as the party that gave it.
In a chartered voyage the carrier deals with its charterer. The charterer asks for the release, so the charterer gives the LOI, addressed to the shipowner and naming the vessel, the voyage, the cargo, the bills of lading by number, and the party the cargo is to be delivered to. Standard wordings for this purpose have been published by the shipowners' liability associations, and carriers can insist on one of them, or on their own form.
A trader that charters the vessel and has sold the cargo on is in the middle. It gives an LOI to the carrier for a cargo it is releasing to its buyer, and it asks the buyer for an LOI in return, so that a claim against it can be passed on. Where the buyer has sold on again, the request goes down the chain to the receiver who actually takes the cargo.
This is where the first check belongs. The LOI a trader receives is meant to cover the LOI it gives. If the two wordings differ, in the obligations they contain, in the amount they cover, in how long they last or in the law that governs them, the difference is the trader's own exposure. A back-to-back pair that is not back to back leaves a gap that only shows when a claim comes through.
The indemnity obligations go beyond paying a loss: defending claims, putting up security, and handing over the originals once they appear
An LOI for delivery without the original bill is a promise of several things, not of one. The issuer undertakes to compensate the carrier for the consequences of the release, to fund its defence if it is sued, to provide security if the vessel is arrested, and to deliver the originals to the carrier as soon as they are obtained.
The core of an LOI is an indemnity: the issuer undertakes to hold the carrier, and in the standard wordings its agents and employees, harmless against liability, loss, damage and expense arising from the delivery. That covers a claim by the holder of the bill for the value of the cargo, and the costs of dealing with it.
Several further indemnity obligations sit around that core in the standard wordings. The issuer undertakes to provide the carrier with funds to defend proceedings brought against it over the delivery. It undertakes to provide security, such as bail or a guarantee, to release the vessel or any other vessel in the same ownership if it is arrested or threatened with arrest because of the delivery. It undertakes to deliver the original bills of lading to the carrier as soon as they come into its possession, which is what eventually brings the LOI to an end. Where more than one party signs, their liability can be joint and several, so that the carrier can claim the whole amount from any of them.
The amount can be left unlimited or capped, for example at a multiple of the cargo's value. The LOI can run without an end date, staying in force until the originals are delivered up, or it can set a period. It names a governing law and a forum for disputes. Each of these is a term that has to be read in the wording that is actually signed, and the meaning of each depends on that wording and on the governing law.
None of this is a template. The obligations above describe what an LOI of this kind contains, so that a reader knows what to look for. Which wording a party should give or accept is a matter for its legal advisers.
The exposure is to whoever holds the originals and was not paid, and it lasts until the originals are back with the carrier
Once the cargo is released against an LOI, the question is whether anyone other than the receiver holds an original and has a right to the cargo. If someone does, they can claim against the carrier, the carrier claims under the LOI, and the issuer claims under the one it received. The liability exposure is open for as long as an original is outside the chain.
In the ordinary case the originals turn up later, travel down the chain to the receiver, and are handed to the carrier. The LOI is then discharged. Nobody claims, and the LOI is remembered as a formality.
The case it exists for is the other one. A bank that financed the cargo can hold the originals as security and not have been repaid. A seller further up the chain can hold them because it was never paid. A buyer can fail between taking the cargo and paying for it, leaving an unpaid seller with the bills and nothing else. In each case the holder of an original claims the cargo or its value from the carrier, because the carrier released it to someone else. The carrier claims under the LOI it holds. The issuer pays and turns to the LOI it received from its own buyer, which may be the party that failed.
Holding the bill and owning the cargo can be two different things, and a bank holding the bill as security is the plain case. How title, risk and delivery separate on one cargo is set out here. Title Transfer in Commodity Trading, and How It Differs From Risk and Delivery
The exposure therefore has a start and an end that are both recorded somewhere. It starts on the day the cargo is released. It ends on the day the originals are surrendered to the carrier, or on a date the LOI itself sets. Between the two, the issuer carries a contingent liability for up to the value of the cargo and the costs around it, and the size of what it can recover depends on who gave it the matching LOI.
The life of a release without an original can be read as one path. The vessel arrives. If an original bill is presented, the cargo is released against it. If not, the carrier asks the party seeking the cargo for an LOI. If that party's credit and the internal approval for issuing the LOI are not in place, there is no release and the cargo waits for the originals. If they are, the LOI is issued, a matching LOI is taken from the buyer where there is one, and the cargo is released. From then on the question is whether a holder of an original comes forward to claim the cargo. If none does, the originals are found and surrendered to the carrier, and the LOI is discharged. If one does, the carrier claims under the LOI, and the issuer claims in turn under the one it holds.
An LOI replaces the protection the carrier lacks, and creates a liability the issuer's insurance does not cover
An LOI does not put any insurance back in place. The carrier asks for it because its own liability cover can exclude delivery without the bill. The issuer takes on a contractual liability, and cargo insurance, which pays for physical loss of or damage to goods, is not cover for a promise to indemnify.
It is easy to read an LOI as closing a gap: the cargo was waiting, the LOI was signed, the cargo was delivered, and everything is covered again. The gap has not closed. It has moved. The carrier's exposure is now backed by the issuer's promise instead of by insurance. The issuer's exposure is backed by the matching LOI it received, if it received one, and by nothing else.
Cargo insurance does not fill that space. It responds to physical loss of or damage to the goods in transit. A claim by the holder of a bill that the cargo was delivered to the wrong party is not physical loss or damage, and the issuer's liability under its LOI is a liability it chose to accept. Whether a release against an LOI affects any other cover the issuer holds is a question for its insurers, and the answer depends on the terms of its own policies.
The carrier's liability cover protects the carrier, not the cargo, and cargo insurance pays only for what its terms cover. How to check a cargo policy against the trade it covers is set out here. Cargo Insurance in Commodity Trading: How to Check Your Policy Against the Trade
An LOI is worth the creditworthiness of whoever signed it, so it is checked and approved like a credit line
An LOI is an unsecured promise. Its value to the party holding it is the ability of the party that gave it to pay when called, possibly years later. Counterparty creditworthiness is therefore the first check on an LOI received, and the approval to give one is a decision to take on a contingent liability.
For the carrier, the strength of an LOI is the strength of its issuer. Where the issuer's own standing is not enough, the carrier can require a bank to countersign the LOI or to issue a guarantee behind it, so that the obligation is backed by the bank's credit rather than the trader's.
For a trader in the middle of a chain, the same logic applies twice. The LOI it gives is a liability it carries until the originals are surrendered. The LOI it receives from its buyer is an asset worth only what that buyer can pay, and a failure of that buyer is exactly the kind of event that would cause the LOI to be called. A trader that would not extend open credit to a buyer for the full value of a cargo is extending something close to it when it gives an LOI for that cargo backed only by the buyer's own LOI.
That is why the approval belongs with credit and legal, and not only with operations. The request arrives from operations, under time pressure, as a step needed to release a waiting vessel. The decision is a credit decision: whether to accept a contingent liability up to the value of the cargo, with recourse to a named counterparty for an open period.
A release without an original leaves three records to keep: the LOIs, the delivery, and where the originals are
An LOI is closed by an event that happens later and elsewhere: the surrender of the originals to the carrier. Until then three records have to be kept and kept together: the LOIs given and received, the delivery made against them, and the location of the originals. A trading business that keeps them apart cannot say which of its LOIs are still open.
The LOI record holds each LOI given and each received: the parties, the vessel and voyage, the cargo, the bill of lading numbers, the contract it relates to, the amount or cap, any countersigning bank, the governing law, the date, any expiry, who approved it, and its status. Each LOI given is paired with the LOI received for the same cargo, and the differences between the two wordings are recorded rather than assumed away.
The delivery record holds what happened at discharge: the date, the place, the party the cargo was released to, the quantity, and the basis of the release, whether against an original or against an LOI. It is the evidence of what the LOI was given for.
The originals record holds where the bills are: with which bank, seller or buyer, since when, and when they are expected. It is the record that eventually closes the LOI, and the one that is easiest to lose, because it changes hands outside the company and nobody's work is done when it arrives.
Each record a release against an LOI needs, who keeps it, and what it is checked against
| Record | What it holds | Kept by | Checked against | What a gap means |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LOI given | The obligations, amount or cap, governing law, expiry and parties of the promise to the carrier | Legal and operations | The LOI received for the same cargo | A liability with no matching recourse |
| LOI received | The buyer's promise back, on the same points | Legal and operations | The LOI given | Recourse that is narrower, smaller or shorter than the liability it is meant to cover |
| Issuer's credit | The standing of each party whose LOI is held, and any bank countersignature | Credit | The value of the cargo and the open period | A promise worth less than the claim it would have to meet |
| Approval | Who approved the LOI, under what authority, on what date | Credit and legal | The company's approval limits | A contingent liability nobody decided to take on |
| Delivery | Date, place, receiver, quantity and basis of the release | Operations | The bills of lading and the LOI | A release that cannot be tied to the promise given for it |
| Originals | Where each original bill is, since when, and when it is expected | Trade finance and operations | The open LOIs | An LOI that stays open because nobody is chasing the bills |
| Closure | The date the originals were surrendered to the carrier and the LOI discharged | Operations and legal | The LOI given and the LOI received | Liabilities reported as open after they ended, or as closed while they are still live |
Read the last column. None of these gaps shows in the ordinary run of trades, because in the ordinary run nobody claims. Each one shows on the day a holder of an original does, and the records that would have answered the claim are the ones that were filled in at the moment of release or not at all.
Questions people ask about this
What is a letter of indemnity in shipping?
A letter of indemnity, or LOI, is a written undertaking by one party to compensate another for the consequences of an act done at its request. In commodity shipping the main use is cargo delivery without the original bills of lading: the party asking for the cargo gives the carrier an LOI so that the carrier will release the cargo before an original is presented.
Why does a carrier ask for an LOI to release cargo without the original bill of lading?
Because under an order bill the carrier is obliged to deliver against an original, and if it delivers to anyone else it can be liable to the holder of the bill. Its own liability insurance can exclude that liability, or cover it only at the insurer's discretion. The LOI gives the carrier a contractual right to be compensated by the party that asked for the release.
Who gives the LOI, and who does it protect?
The party instructing the carrier to release the cargo gives it, which in a chartered voyage is the charterer, and it protects the carrier. A charterer that has sold the cargo on can ask its buyer for a matching LOI, and each buyer down the chain can ask the next, so that a claim can be passed back along the chain.
What obligations does an LOI for delivery without the original bill create?
The issuer undertakes to indemnify the carrier against liability, loss, damage and expense arising from the delivery, to provide funds for the carrier's defence if it is sued, to provide security if a vessel is arrested over the delivery, and to deliver the original bills to the carrier once it obtains them. The exact obligations, any cap and any expiry depend on the wording signed and on the governing law.
Does an LOI restore insurance cover?
No. The carrier asks for an LOI because its liability insurance can exclude delivery without the bill, and the LOI does not put that cover back. The issuer's liability under the LOI is a contractual promise, and cargo insurance, which pays for physical loss of or damage to goods, does not cover it. Whether a release affects any other policy the issuer holds is a question for its insurers.
What happens if the holder of the original bill of lading claims the cargo?
The holder can claim against the carrier for releasing the cargo to someone else. The carrier then claims under the LOI, and the issuer pays and claims in turn under any LOI it received from its own buyer. What the issuer recovers depends on the wording of that LOI and on the buyer's ability to pay.
How long does an LOI stay in force?
Until the wording says it ends. An LOI for delivery without the original bill can run without an expiry date, staying in force until the originals are delivered up to the carrier, or it can set a period. Until it ends, the issuer carries a contingent liability, which is why the location of the originals has to be tracked.
Should an LOI be countersigned by a bank?
That depends on the issuer's standing and on what the carrier or the counterparty will accept. A bank countersignature or guarantee backs the promise with the bank's credit instead of the issuer's. For a party receiving an LOI, the question is whether the issuer alone could pay a claim up to the value of the cargo, possibly long after the release.
How should LOIs be recorded in a trading system?
As a liability and an asset attached to the cargo they concern: each LOI given and received, with its parties, bill numbers, amount or cap, expiry, approval and status, paired with its counterpart, linked to the delivery made against it and to a record of where the originals are. That is what allows the open LOIs, and the exposure behind them, to be listed by counterparty at any time.
Where this lands in a trading system
Nothing in this article makes the decision to issue or accept an LOI easier. What can be made easier is knowing, at the moment of that decision and afterwards, what is already open, against whom and on which cargo. Part of that maps onto system capabilities.
The first conclusion is that an LOI is a contingent liability or a credit exposure attached to a cargo, and it has to be held next to the trade, the cargo, the delivery and the counterparty it concerns. It is the job of a CTRM/ETRM system providing complete trading lifecycle management for commodity traders, integrating physical trade, financial hedging, risk control, and settlement in one platform; Time Dynamics' Fusion is one, and the parts of it that bear on this article are complete physical trade lifecycle management and execution, end-to-end logistics coordination and execution management and comprehensive risk assessment and monitoring capabilities. Holding each LOI next to the cargo, the bills of lading and the counterparty is the condition under which open LOIs can be counted as exposure to a named party rather than discovered one at a time when a claim arrives.
The second conclusion is that open LOIs have to be listed and reviewed: by counterparty, by age, by whether the originals have been located. That is a recurring report rather than a one-off search. X-Ray's reporting component X-Sheet provides one-click generation of personalized reports with Excel-like interface. Whether it is pointed at an LOI register is a configuration question rather than something a platform decides for you, but a list of open items by counterparty and age is an ordinary report, not an exotic one.
One conclusion of this article is deliberately not mapped. Whether to release a cargo without an original, whether to give or accept a particular LOI, whether its wording is adequate, and whether it would be enforceable under its governing law are decisions for operations, credit and legal. They do not correspond to anything on the published capability list, and the honest thing to do is leave them unmapped.
Here the mapping ends. None of this drafts, signs or approves an LOI, and none of it replaces a bank countersignature. It does not read an LOI's wording, it does not decide whether a cargo may be released, it does not assess whether a promise is enforceable, and it does not provide insurance. What it can hold is the record: which LOIs are open, against whom, for which cargo, and where the originals that would close them are.
A note on the evidence in this article
There are no statistics in this article. The observations behind it, about how LOIs are requested, approved and closed, come from material we are not in a position to publish as a citable figure, and a figure no reader could check would have added weight without adding anything a reader could use.
So the argument is made from the mechanism, and each step can be tested against your own records. List the LOIs your company has given in the last period. For each, find the LOI received for the same cargo and compare the two wordings on obligations, amount, expiry and governing law. Then find where the originals for that cargo are today and whether they have been surrendered to the carrier. Finally, add up the open LOIs by counterparty and compare the total with the credit you would extend to that counterparty openly. Where any of those answers needs a mailbox, that is the finding. If your records behave differently from what is described here, your records are the better evidence.
The obligations an LOI creates, and whether they can be enforced, depend on its actual wording and on the law that governs it, and the rules differ between jurisdictions. This article describes what such letters contain and how they relate to the records a trading business keeps. It does not provide wording to use, it does not treat an LOI as restoring any insurance cover, and for any particular LOI the answer is a matter for legal advice.
An LOI lets the cargo go before the bill arrives. It does not let the liability go with it.