In Short

A bill of lading records the cargo as it was loaded: what was shipped, how much, from where to where, on what date and to whose order. The contract records what was agreed. This guide sets out each field on the bill, where it comes from, and how it is matched against the contract, the voyage and the delivery records.

A bill of lading is the document a carrier issues once a cargo is on board. It records what was shipped, in what apparent condition, on which vessel, from which port to which port, on what date, and to whose order the cargo will be delivered. It is a receipt for the goods, evidence of the terms on which they are carried and, when it is made out to order, the document the cargo is released against at the other end. It is not a copy of the sale contract. The contract describes the range of cargoes the seller may deliver: a quantity with a tolerance, a grade with specification limits, a load port or a range of ports, a delivery period. The bill describes the one cargo that was actually loaded, in the carrier's words, at one moment. Every other record of the trade, from the nomination to the invoice to the release at discharge, has to be matched to that single description, and the matching is a test of fit rather than of equality.

This article sets out what a bill of lading records field by field, who writes each field and from what, how the bill's cargo description, quantity, ports and receiving parties correspond to the sale contract, to the voyage and to the delivery records at discharge, and when a field can still be changed. It is written for the people who handle the bill from instruction to release: the operations and shipping teams who send instructions to the carrier, the documentation and trade finance teams who check and present it, the settlement teams who invoice against it, and the traders whose contracts it has to satisfy.

If the document is new to you, start with A bill of lading is the carrier's record of a cargo as it was loaded. If you already handle bills and want the part that goes wrong quietly, start with The contract describes a range of cargoes and the bill describes one, so matching them is a test of fit, not of equality.

A bill of lading is the carrier's record of a cargo as it was loaded

The bill is issued by the carrier, or by the master or an agent on its behalf, after the goods are on board. It does three jobs at once: it acknowledges that the goods described were received, it evidences the terms on which they are carried, and, when it is made out to order, it is the document the cargo is delivered against at discharge.

The first job is the receipt. The carrier states what it received and in what apparent order and condition. The word "apparent" matters. The carrier looks at the cargo from the outside and does not test it, so the bill can say that goods were shipped in good order without saying anything about their quality. A bill with no remark against the condition of the goods is called clean. A bill carrying a remark, such as damaged packaging or a shortfall the carrier noticed, is called claused, and a buyer or a bank that requires a clean bill can refuse it.

The second job is the contract of carriage. Where the vessel is chartered, the bill can incorporate the charter party's terms by reference, so part of what governs the carriage sits in a document the bill only names. The holder of the bill may never have seen it.

The third job is the one that makes the bill more than a receipt. A bill made out to order can be transferred by endorsement and delivery, and at discharge the carrier delivers the cargo to the party presenting an original. A bill made out to a named consignee cannot be transferred that way. The bill is issued as a set of originals, with the number stated on its face, and once one of them has been used to take delivery the others stand void. How the transfer of a bill relates to the transfer of the goods, and what it does and does not pass, is a subject of its own. For this article it is enough that the bill is the record the cargo's release is checked against.

Of the shipping documents in a physical trade, the bill is the one written by a party outside the sale, at the moment of loading, about what was loaded. That is what makes it the fixed point the other records are matched to.

Each field on the bill is written from the shipping instructions and the load port's figures, not from your contract

The fields on a bill come from three places: the shipping instructions the shipper or its agent sends, the measurement taken at loading, and the carrier's own record of the vessel and the voyage. None of them comes from the sale contract, and the bill does not need the contract to be valid.

The parties come from the shipping instructions. The shipper is the party named as having handed the goods to the carrier. The consignee is the party the cargo is to be delivered to: a named company, or "to order", or "to the order of" a named party such as a bank financing the trade. The notify party is the party the carrier or its agent informs when the vessel arrives. Being named as notify party gives no right to the cargo. It is an address for a message.

The cargo description is written in the carrier's terms from what the instructions gave it. It can be more general than the contract: a product name rather than a grade with its quality limits, with the quality itself evidenced by a separate certificate from an inspector. The shipment quantity comes from the measurement at the load port, by shore tank, meter, draught survey or weighing, depending on the cargo. The carrier records a figure it did not produce itself, and the bill can say so, with words such as "said to contain" or "weight unknown". The vessel can take its own figure as well. The bill records one quantity.

The vessel, the voyage and the port of loading are the carrier's facts. The port of discharge comes from the instructions and names where the cargo is going at the moment of issue. The date is the date the goods were shipped on board, alongside the place and date the bill was issued. The freight terms state whether freight has been paid or is payable under the charter party.

Each of these was written for the carrier's purposes: to know what it is carrying, from where, to where, and to whom it has to hand it over. They become evidence for the sale contract, the credit, the invoice and the pricing only because those documents point at the bill.

The contract describes a range of cargoes and the bill describes one, so matching them is a test of fit, not of equality

A sale contract for a physical cargo states what the seller may deliver: a quantity with a tolerance, a grade with specification limits, a load port or a range, a delivery period. The bill states what was delivered to the ship. The question for each field is whether the bill's value falls inside what the contract allowed, and that question cannot be answered unless the contract's limits are recorded as data rather than left as text in the contract.

Quantity shows the difference most clearly. The contract names a quantity and a tolerance around it, which can be at one party's option. The bill shows the quantity loaded. Compared for equality, the two disagree whenever the loading lands anywhere but exactly on the contract figure, and the comparison stops meaning anything. Compared for fit, the question becomes whether the loaded figure sits inside the tolerance, and whose option the tolerance was. A loading outside the tolerance is a contract question, and it is known on the day the bill is issued. Found at invoicing, the same fact is weeks older and harder to raise.

The cargo description fits in a different way. The contract specifies the grade. The bill names the product, and the inspector's certificate carries the quality. The bill is checked for consistency with the contract rather than for repeating it, and a description that names a different product from the one traded is a finding, while a description that is simply more general is not.

Ports fit against what the contract fixed and what it left open. The contract can name one load port or a range, and it can leave the discharge port for the buyer to declare later. The bill names one of each at issue. When the destination changes after the bill was issued, for example because the cargo was resold during the voyage, the bill and the voyage stop agreeing, and how that is resolved is a matter for the parties and the carrier.

The date carries the most consequences. The bill's date has to fall inside the contract's delivery period, and a contract can key other terms to it: the window of quotations that prices the cargo, the day payment falls due, and, under a letter of credit, the latest date by which shipment had to happen. A loading that slips by a day moves each of those with it.

A bill of lading date that moves can move the price with it. Why a delay at loading is also a repricing is worked through here. Crude Oil Trading: Why the Barrel You Hedge Is Not the Barrel You Own

The parties fit against the payment terms. A contract paid under a letter of credit can require the bill to be made out to the order of a bank, and a bill made out to the buyer instead is a bill the bank will not accept. A contract on open terms can leave the consignee to the seller's instructions. Either way, the consignee is a payment and security decision written into the bill, and it is checked against the terms that made it, not against the buyer's name.

The bill and the nomination describe the same lifting from two sides, and one cargo can be split across several bills

Before loading, the cargo exists in the nomination and the shipping instructions: a vessel, a planned quantity, a window, a destination. The bill replaces the plan with what happened. Between the two sit the differences that operations already knows about and the rest of the company has not yet been told: a different quantity, a substituted vessel, a later date.

The nominated quantity is a plan made inside the contract's tolerance. The loaded quantity is what the terminal delivered, and it can differ for reasons that have nothing to do with the contract: the shore tank held less than expected, the vessel stopped loading at its draught limit, the terminal's measurement and the vessel's differed. A vessel can be substituted after nomination, with the buyer's acceptance, and the bill will name the vessel that sailed. The bill is the moment those differences become documents. Up to then they live in emails between operations and the terminal.

A cargo can also be issued as several bills rather than one. A shipper can ask for split bills so that parcels sold to different buyers each have their own document, so that each bill fits an amount under a different credit, or because a buyer asked for it. One contract can then be delivered under several bills, and one bill can carry a parcel serving more than one contract. Each bill has its own number, and that number is a key the contract record does not share.

The bill number is one more identifier the cargo carries that nothing else in the trade is keyed to. Why the joins between those identifiers are made by hand is set out here. Cargo Scheduling: Why the Plan Is Binding Before Anything Records It

Before issue a field on the bill is an instruction you can correct, and after issue it is a document only the carrier can replace

Every field on the bill was, a short time before, a line in the shipping instructions or a figure on a load port report. That is the moment a wrong field costs an email. Once the bill is signed and the originals are released, correcting it means asking the carrier to issue a replacement, and the carrier can require the full set of originals back first, wherever they have travelled by then.

The check that works is the one made on the draft. Where the carrier or its agent circulates a draft bill before signing, document verification is a comparison of that draft against four things: the contract's limits, for fit; the letter of credit, if there is one, for its exact words; the nomination, for vessel and ports; and the instructions themselves, for the parties. Each of those comparisons can be made before the bill exists. After it exists, each one becomes a request to an organisation that has no stake in your trade's deadlines.

When the bill has to be presented under a letter of credit, a field that differs from the credit is a discrepancy, and the carrier is not the only party you then depend on. What a discrepancy does to payment is worked through here. Letter of Credit Discrepancies: Why a Typo Hands the Decision Back to Your Buyer

The corrections that are cheap are therefore the ones made to your own instructions. The ones that are expensive are the ones made to the carrier's document. A difference found late has to be resolved in your own records, because they are the ones that can still be changed.

At discharge, the bill is compared with what arrived and with who is asking for the cargo

Two comparisons happen at the discharge port. The quantity on the bill is compared with the quantity that came out of the ship, and the party asking for the cargo is compared with the party the bill says it should go to. The first produces a difference that somebody owns under the contract. The second decides whether the carrier releases the cargo at all.

The outturn is measured at discharge, and it is not the bill quantity. The difference between the two is the voyage and the measurement: what was lost or gained in transit, and what two different measurements at two different ports would have disagreed about anyway. Which of the two quantities the sale is invoiced on is a contract term, and it decides who carries the difference. A difference beyond what the contract or the terms of carriage allow becomes a shortage claim, and claims of that kind are a separate subject. The point for this article is that every such comparison starts from the bill's figure, so a bill quantity that was wrong at loading makes every later comparison wrong too.

Loaded and discharged quantities are two facts about one cargo, and the contract decides which one is priced. How that changes the invoice on the same cargo is worked through here. LNG Trading: Why the Cargo, Not the Volume, Is the Unit of Exposure

Cargo release follows the bill. For a bill made out to order, the carrier delivers against presentation of an original, endorsed to the party presenting it. The notify party is told that the vessel has arrived and is not, by being told, entitled to anything. Where a cargo has been sold on during the voyage, the originals may still be moving through a chain of sellers, buyers and banks when the vessel arrives. The cargo can then be released only on another basis, such as a letter of indemnity from the party asking for it, and that route carries risks of its own that are outside this article.

The life of an order bill can therefore be read as one path with one loop and one exit. The shipping instructions produce a draft bill. If the draft does not match the contract and, where there is one, the credit, the instructions are corrected and a new draft follows. If it matches, the bill is issued and signed, and the originals travel to the holder. At discharge, if an original is presented, the cargo is released to the holder. If none is presented, release can only happen on another basis, such as an indemnity, and that is a different path with different risks, not a shortcut to the same end.

The life of an order bill of lading, from instruction to releaseShipping instructions produce a draft bill, which is corrected until it matches the contract and the credit and then issued. Its originals travel to the holder, and at discharge the cargo is released to the holder if an original is presented, or only on another basis if none is.nonew draft followsyesyesnoShipping instructionsDraft billMatches contractand credit?Instructions correctedBill issued and signedOriginals travel to the holderOriginal presentedat discharge?Cargo released to the holderRelease only on another basis,such as an indemnity

Each field on the bill is matched against a term in the contract and a record in transport or delivery

Field on the billWritten fromMatched in the contract againstMatched in transport and delivery againstWhat a difference points to
ShipperThe shipping instructionsThe seller, or the party the contract or credit requiresThe party that delivered the goods at the load portA chain in which the seller is not the party that loaded
ConsigneeThe shipping instructionsThe payment terms: to order, to a bank's order, or a named buyerThe party entitled to take deliveryA bill a bank will not accept, or a release to the wrong party
Notify partyThe shipping instructionsWhoever the contract or credit namesWho is told that the vessel has arrivedA missed arrival notice, and nothing about entitlement
Vessel and voyageThe carrierThe nominated and accepted vesselThe nomination and the voyage recordA substitution not recorded on the trade
Port of loadingThe carrierThe load port or range in the contractThe nominationA delivery outside the agreed range
Port of dischargeThe shipping instructionsThe named port, or the buyer's declared optionWhere the vessel actually goesA destination changed after issue
Cargo descriptionThe shipping instructions, in the carrier's termsThe grade, with quality evidenced by a separate certificateThe product as held in inventoryA grade recorded one way on the trade and another on the documents
Shipment quantityThe load port measurementThe contract quantity and its toleranceThe nominated quantity before loading, the outturn after dischargeA loading outside tolerance, or a voyage difference to be allocated
Apparent order and conditionThe carrier's observationA requirement for a clean bill, in the contract or the creditThe condition found at dischargeA claused bill a buyer or bank can refuse
Shipped on board dateThe carrierThe delivery period, and any pricing or payment terms keyed to itThe loading recordA repricing, a moved due date or a missed shipment date
Set of originalsThe carrier, with the number on the faceThe documents required for paymentThe release at dischargeA delivery that has to be arranged without one

Read across any row. The field in the first two columns ends up in a document signed by someone outside the trade, at one moment, in words that cannot be edited afterwards. The records in the third and fourth columns are kept by you and can be corrected. That is why the bill is the fixed point the others are matched to, and why the useful question about each field is not "is it the same as the contract" but "is it inside what the contract allowed, and does every later record start from it".

Questions people ask about this

What is a bill of lading in commodity trading?

A bill of lading is the document a carrier issues after loading a cargo. It acknowledges what was received and in what apparent condition, evidences the terms on which the goods are carried, and, when it is made out to order, is the document the carrier delivers the cargo against at discharge. In a physical commodity trade it is the record of the cargo as it was loaded, and the contract, the credit, the invoice and the release at discharge all refer to it.

What information is on a bill of lading?

The shipper, the consignee and the notify party; the vessel and voyage; the ports of loading and discharge; a description of the goods and the marks on them; the quantity shipped; a statement of their apparent order and condition; the date the goods were shipped on board, with the place and date of issue; the freight terms; and the number of originals in the set. Each field comes from the shipping instructions, the load port measurement or the carrier's own record, not from the sale contract.

Why is the bill of lading quantity different from the contract quantity?

Because they record different things. The contract states a quantity with a tolerance, which is the range the seller may deliver. The bill states the quantity measured at loading, which is what was actually delivered to the ship. The useful check is whether the bill quantity falls inside the contract's tolerance and whose option the tolerance was. The bill quantity will also differ from the outturn at discharge, and which of the two the invoice is based on is a term of the sale contract.

What is the difference between the consignee and the notify party on a bill of lading?

The consignee is the party the cargo is to be delivered to: a named company, or the order of the shipper, a buyer or a bank. The notify party is only the party the carrier or its agent informs when the vessel arrives. Being named as notify party gives no right to take the cargo. Under an order bill, the cargo goes to whoever presents a properly endorsed original.

Why does the bill of lading date matter?

Because a sale contract can key several terms to it. The date has to fall inside the contract's delivery period, and the contract can use it to set the window of quotations that prices the cargo and the day payment falls due. Under a letter of credit it is compared with the latest permitted shipment date. A loading that slips can therefore move the price, the payment date and the compliance of the documents at the same time.

Can a bill of lading be corrected after it has been issued?

Only by the carrier, which issued it. A correction means asking the carrier to issue a replacement, and the carrier can require the full set of originals to be returned before it does, wherever they have travelled by then. That is why the check belongs on the draft bill, before signing, when a wrong field is still a line in your own shipping instructions.

What happens if the ship arrives before the original bill of lading?

Under an order bill, the carrier delivers against an original, so without one the cargo cannot be released in the ordinary way. This can happen when a cargo has been sold on during the voyage and the originals are still moving through the chain of sellers, buyers and banks. The cargo can then be released only on another basis, such as a letter of indemnity from the party asking for it, which carries risks of its own for the parties who give and accept it.

What is a clean bill of lading?

A clean bill is one on which the carrier has made no remark against the apparent order and condition of the goods or their packaging. A bill carrying such a remark is called claused. A clean bill says nothing about the quality of the cargo, because the carrier inspects only its outward condition. Contracts and letters of credit can require a clean bill, and a claused one can then be refused.

Which documents should a bill of lading be checked against?

Before it is signed, against the sale contract for fit within its limits, the letter of credit if there is one for its exact wording, the nomination for the vessel and the ports, and the shipping instructions for the parties. After discharge, its quantity is compared with the outturn and its consignee with the party asking for the cargo. The first set of checks can still change the bill. The second can only explain it.

Where this lands in a trading system

Nothing above is an argument for buying software. It is an argument about where the bill's fields have to sit relative to the contract, the voyage and the delivery, and about when they can still be changed. Some of that maps onto system capabilities, and it is worth being exact about which parts.

The first conclusion is that a bill is checked for fit against the contract's limits, and that its quantity and date then carry into pricing, invoicing and inventory. That needs the bill's fields stored as data next to the trade and the cargo they belong to. It is the job of a CTRM/ETRM system providing complete trading lifecycle management for commodity traders, integrating physical trade, financial hedging, risk control, and settlement in one platform; Time Dynamics' Fusion is one, and the parts of it that bear on this article are complete physical trade lifecycle management and execution, end-to-end logistics coordination and execution management, real-time inventory tracking and optimization and automated financial settlement and payment processing. Holding the contract's terms, the nomination, the bill and the invoice in one place is the condition under which a loaded quantity can be checked against a tolerance rather than against a single number, and under which the quantity on an invoice can be traced back to the bill it came from.

The second conclusion is that the bill's fields reach the company as a document, and are keyed by hand into a spreadsheet or held in an agent's web interface before anything else uses them. That is what X-Ray addresses: a non-invasive data processing and analysis platform whose collection toolkit XDK performs non-invasive automated data collection from databases, Excel files, and web interfaces, and which is built to collect data without disrupting existing systems or workflows. The last property matters here, because the register a documentation team keeps of its bills is working, and the first step is to read it rather than replace it. It reads where the bill's fields already are once someone has entered them. It does not read the scanned bill.

One conclusion of this article is deliberately not mapped. Whether a bill is acceptable under a contract or a credit, whether a loaded quantity outside tolerance is a breach, and whether a cargo may be released without an original are decisions for operations, trade finance and legal. They do not correspond to anything on the published capability list, and the honest thing to do is leave them unmapped.

And here is where the rest stops. None of this issues a bill, and none of it is the carrier's record. It does not examine a presentation against a credit, it does not decide who holds title to a cargo, and it does not decide whether a cargo can be released without an original. What a system can settle here is narrower than the problem in this article: whether each bill's fields are stored next to the contract and the cargo they belong to, whether the contract's tolerances are data a loaded quantity can be checked against, and whether anyone can say, for a given cargo, which bills it was shipped under and which contracts each one serves. That covers a real part of the work. The judgement stays where it was.

A note on the evidence in this article

There are no statistics in this article, and that is a decision rather than an oversight. The observations behind it, about how bills are checked and where their differences from the contract are found, come from material we are not in a position to publish as a citable figure. A number nobody could check would make the argument look stronger and make it worth less.

So the argument is made from the mechanism, and each step can be tested against your own cargoes. Take the last few cargoes you shipped. For each, line up the contract quantity and its tolerance, the nominated quantity, the bill quantity and the outturn, using only what is stored today. Then check whether each bill date sits inside the contract's delivery period, and where the pricing and payment dates keyed to it were recorded. Finally, for one cargo, find out who held the originals on the day the vessel arrived. Where you had to open a mailbox to answer, that is the finding. If your cargoes behave differently from what is described here, your cargoes are the better evidence.

The legal effect of a bill depends on the law and the international rules that govern it, and on the terms of the sale contract and any credit. Those differ by jurisdiction and by trade. This article describes the records and how they relate to one another, not the law that applies to them.

The contract says what may be loaded. The bill says what was.

Discuss your cargo documents →